"There appears to be much more of a controversy surrounding the animelyrics.com dissolved partnership than I had at first been led to believe."I quote what I found from the original gendou.com forums post about the controversy and conflict in between the domain owner of animelyrics.com and the person who had coded the whole website. As far as I have read about it in Gendou's forum, I can see that both Igor Bass (domain owner of animelyrics.com) and Philip Mak (coded majority of the site) are both unhappy with each other. According to their agreement which was made in 2001, for contributing the domain name, Philip (who owns the actual server) had allowed Igor to post advertistments (read: Google ads) on the site as per the partnership agreement. But slowly, Philip started to remove Igor's ads and added his own.As time goes on, Igor was fed up of allowing Philip to use the domain for his own profit. Philip, on the other hand, had offered Igor $5,000 for the domain and $90,000 for the site content with it, but Igor had refused, and called the offer an insult to him. This had prompted Philip to move the contents as well as returning visitors to his own new domain, animelyrics.tv, which now resides all of the anime lyrics, including old and new ones. Personally, I do not know whose side to be on, although I do favour animelyrics.tv more as of now. According to Sailor Bacon, the former administrator of the database in Animelyrics.com, Igor had never done a thing at all to help the site, and that he had been getting free money from the ads. But according to another guy, Igor wasn't able to access the server at all, in other words, barred from the server, thus having no power at all to make changes. In this case, Igor could have did something, since he is the actual owner of the domain, but he didn't until it was too late.As far as I am concerned, no improvements (read: no new anime lyrics) were made between the period in 2004-2006 when Sailor Bacon left Animelyrics, however Xazy, the person who took over from Sailor Bacon as Admin, claimed that there are still updates during the period, it's just that the update page wasn't updated at least in animelyrics.tv. Now, as I have browsed through animelyrics.tv's database, I can see new lyrics such as Asatte no Houkou's "Hikari no Kisetsu" and "Yuki, Muon, Madobe Nite", Yuki's character song from The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya. I still remember the days when, if I were to search for lyrics for the Digimon songs that I had downloaded, I were to go to animelyrics.com. The lyrics are already there, mainly contributed by megchan or Izzy (read: not Sailorbeacon nor Xazy), and they were really convenient. Some time ago, Animelyrics.com were never to fail me if I were to search for old anime lyrics such as Chuuka Ichiban's "Ikki mo Dekinai" which I cannot find anywhere else; but when it comes to songs from newer animes such as "being" from Shakugan no Shana and "Aoi Field" from Suzuka, I don't see a lyric at all, not to mention that the animes weren't even listed at that time despite the anime had already finish showing! "being" and "Aoi Field" together with a few other songs are now available in .tv, though, after the November update (a few linked me back to Darkmirage's Lyric Translation page. How scary was that?). I guess I should visit animelyrics.tv the next time I were to find anime song lyrics. Hmm.In any case, Gendou is building up their own lyric database and stop being dependent on external sources. Plus, they do not have any advertistments on their server. Two thumbs up for them. The case is now closed for them, but it's not for the fans of animes. We'll see how the outcome would be in the end. Would Patrick get sued? Would Igor finally sell the domain to Patrick?
(Read the rest of this entry)
(Entry meta)
